Israel Expels Russians and Ukrainians
Unsplash
Israel has stopped renewing temporary residence permits for Russian and Ukrainian nationals. Asylum applicants are being ordered to leave the country within seven days, even though returning home could expose them to persecution and criminal prosecution. Knesset member Alex Rif has called for the expulsions to be suspended and for the immigration authority’s decisions to be reviewed.
Permit Renewals Denied
Russians and Ukrainians are increasingly being denied renewals of permits issued while their applications for asylum in Israel are under review. Some have been ordered to leave within seven days. Citizens of Belarus have also been affected. Foreign nationals who have spent years waiting for decisions on their cases now face the threat of expulsion.
The changes began as early as June 2026, when the immigration authority stepped up reviews of older cases and began summoning applicants for interviews more frequently. In September, lawyer Alex Zernopolsky told the publication NANovosti that refusals had become more common following such interviews. Previously, cases could remain unresolved for years while foreign nationals continued to live legally in Israel. Now a negative decision is often accompanied by an order to depart at short notice.
Temporary residence is based on permit 2A5, commonly known as the “blue paper.” It allows applicants to remain in the country while their asylum claims are examined, but does not confer refugee status or the right to permanent residence. Renewing a permit for several years does not guarantee a favorable outcome. A refusal creates a risk of deportation, and challenging it requires going to court.
Knesset Member Appeals to Authorities
Knesset member Alex Rif has demanded a suspension of deportations from Israel involving Russian and Ukrainian nationals whose temporary permits have not been renewed. She sent a letter to Boaz Yosef, head of the Population and Immigration Authority, calling for a review of the decisions affecting asylum seekers.
The letter warns that some applicants returning to Russia could face criminal prosecution and forced military conscription. Ukrainian nationals may encounter serious threats to their safety and lives. Rif argues that these risks should be considered in each individual case before a person is ordered to leave.
The lawmaker also requested an explanation of the increase in refusals and the criteria applied by the immigration authority. Another demand concerns a mechanism for regularizing the status of foreign nationals who cannot safely return to their home countries. Such an approach would allow cases to be assessed individually rather than subjecting every applicant to the same measures.
Thousands of Asylum Applications
Between 2022 and 2025, Russians submitted 4,017 applications for asylum in Israel, the highest total of any nationality over the four-year period. Applications peaked in 2023 at 1,862. The authorities registered 1,012 in 2022, 700 in 2024 and 443 in 2025. The number of Russian nationals seeking protection has therefore declined substantially over the past two years.
|
Year |
Applications |
|
2022 |
1,012 |
|
2023 |
1,862 |
|
2024 |
700 |
|
2025 |
443 |
|
Total |
4,017 |
Meanwhile, the overall number of asylum applications rose by 53% in 2025 to 9,335. Labor migrants from Asia accounted for most of the increase. Sri Lankan nationals submitted 2,815 applications and Indian nationals 1,016, together accounting for 41% of the total. Many originally entered on employment contracts and later sought to change their legal status.
Israel’s immigration policy was discussed in the Knesset in June 2026. Representatives of the relevant authority reported a backlog of 29,600 pending cases. To speed up processing, officials proposed expanding the list of countries considered safe, whose nationals are subject to a simplified review procedure. India, Malawi, Kenya and Sri Lanka are already on that list. The authorities expect the measures to shorten decision times and ease the workload on staff.
Protection Against Deportation
A refusal to renew a temporary permit does not always mean that a foreign national must leave Israel. The legal consequences depend on citizenship and the grounds for staying in the country. Some asylum seekers benefit from additional safeguards, while others must seek a review of the decision on an individual basis.
Russians are not covered by collective protection against expulsion. Each application is assessed separately, taking into account evidence of potential persecution in the applicant’s home country. A negative decision may result in an order to leave, which can be challenged in court. Several years of residence do not, in themselves, create an entitlement to refugee status.
Ukrainians are covered by a special protection arrangement extended until December 31, 2026. Lawyer Alex Zernopolsky explains that protection against deportation remains in force even if a 2A5 permit is not renewed. In other words, the expiry of an individual authorization does not remove the broader safeguards.
|
Criterion |
Russians |
Ukrainians |
|
Collective protection |
No |
Until December 31, 2026 |
|
Asylum review |
Individual |
Individual, with collective safeguards |
|
After a permit refusal |
May be ordered to leave |
Collective protection remains |
|
Permanent residence |
Not guaranteed |
Not guaranteed |
Outlook for Migrants
Analysts at International Investment note that the situation in Israel reflects a global trend toward stricter immigration policies. Changes are particularly visible in Europe and the United States, where authorities are tightening controls on foreign nationals, reviewing asylum requirements and accelerating deportations. Opportunities to remain for extended periods without a secure legal status are narrowing. Even several years of lawful residence do not guarantee a permit renewal.
Ukrainians abroad are in a more favorable position because collective protection applies in the European Union, although the rules are regularly revised and opportunities to stay are being restricted. Russian citizens have no comparable guarantees and must resolve residence-permit issues individually. Israel’s experience shows how vulnerable migrants can be when they rely on automatic extensions of temporary authorization.
In recent years, seeking asylum has become the least reliable route to legal residence. Residence programs based on employment, entrepreneurship or family ties offer more promising options. However, these routes may be inaccessible to the most vulnerable groups of foreign nationals, leaving them at risk of having to move to a third country or face forced removal.
